Much is made of price disparity between such entry-level accounting solutions as QuickBooks® and mid-market stalwarts, including Microsoft Dynamics®. Often, this is comparing apples to oranges. Needs and challenges of a mid-sized company versus a very small business are typically different—and typically warrant different accounting solutions.
Given this scenario, comparing prices is a wasted exercise. Obviously, entry level pricing will be considerably lower than mid-market accounting solutions.
As the price comparison isn’t really a valid consideration, what does matter? Cost. The price paid for accounting software is the money outlay. Cost relates to additional expenditures made necessary because of accounting software shortcomings. Optimally, potential cost issues should be examined prior to buying accounting services—so that a cost/benefit analysis can be conducted. Areas that can become expensive quickly because of a poor accounting software include:
Human capital. If your people don’t take kindly to their accounting software, morale, productivity and longevity issues result. Besides the loss of productivity costs, you may have to hire in trainers and coaches to resolve issues. An employee who leaves often costs a company 70-200% of his/her annual salary for rehiring and retraining. Ka-ching #1.
Audits. Can your accounting software stand up to the typical IRS or other audit? If not, start calculating potential professional fees charged by CPAs, lawyers and other advisors to straighten out problem areas. I was struck by an Oregon newspaper article that stated, “IRS audit costs Sandy Fire District $10,000…The audit was one of the first in a ‘concerted nationwide’ crackdown of fire departments…” Given that our basic Microsoft Dynamics® purchase and implementation is less than $9,000, do the math. Of course, you can always argue that the accounting software wouldn’t have mattered in this case. Possibly.
But, if the IRS is moving to a “concerted nationwide” crackdown on fire departments, other industries are likely to be targeted—particularly as the Treasury Department ratchets up its efforts to find money anywhere to fund our economic bailout. While choice of accounting software can’t guarantee you won’t be audited, it can make a substantial difference. Ka-ching #2.
Security-related regulatory compliance. Entry-level accounting software typically has one layer of security. Mid-market accounting solutions generally offer many layers, and are much harder to hack. An article entitled, “How Much Does a Hack Cost?” pointed out, “According to the annual report by the Computer Security Institute and the FBI, the average loss per company due to security breaches in 2005 was about $167,000…Some rules of thumb say that $100,000 is a good starting point when measuring average loss per incident. Some say $200,000.” Do you really want your accounting system software to function on the low-end of the security scale? Ka-ching #3.
Oscar Wilde said, “A cynic is a man who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing.” Being price-conscious without considering the value of first-class accounting services is shortsighted and potentially very costly in the long run.





